Teamwork · Exercises and training · Preparedness
Your team needs more stress: the case for shared adversity
A shared challenge can reveal strengths, build confidence in colleagues, and give teams a story to draw on. Thoughtful simulation exercises create that opportunity while there is still room to pause, learn, and try again.
Think about the colleagues you would want beside you on a truly awful day.
Chances are, you have already had one together. A system failed. An event went sideways. Everyone had to stay late and figure something out. You saw who kept their head, who noticed you were struggling, and who quietly took something off your plate.
That is the case for giving a team a difficult problem on purpose: a clear objective, a manageable dose of pressure, and a challenge that requires people to rely on one another. Give them room to make mistakes, support each other and work through it.
Waiting for a disaster to provide that experience is an expensive approach to team development. Fortunately, you can practise.
How shared challenges build trust
There is good evidence for practising teamwork. A meta-analysis of 72 controlled training interventions, involving more than 8,000 participants, found improvements in both teamwork and team performance. The approaches studied included simulations, workshops and structured team reviews.[1]
Research on shared challenges offers another piece of the picture. In a field study of 226 teenagers taking part in the Ten Tors outdoor challenge, mutual reliance and support were associated with stronger team bonds afterward.[2]
For workplaces, this suggests a useful direction: create opportunities for people to experience contributing something important, needing help, and receiving it.
A shared challenge gives people opportunities to earn each other’s confidence. It can also reveal strengths that rarely surface in routine meetings.
Give people something to work through together
Picture this: a water leak has closed your building. Staff are arriving. Essential records are inaccessible. A client needs an answer, your usual decision-maker is unavailable, and someone has helpfully suggested that everybody “just work from home.”
Your team has to work out what that actually means.
A tabletop exercise lets people discuss the scenario and work through decisions as a facilitator introduces new developments. A functional exercise has them perform response activities in real time, such as sending exercise messages and coordinating actions, while field operations remain simulated.[3]
Either format can create a shared experience with enough uncertainty to require cooperation.
Who needs to know about the closure? Which work must continue? Who can approve a workaround? The questions cross departmental boundaries, and the people in the room need one another’s knowledge to answer them.
The receptionist knows which clients will arrive before a message reaches them. A quiet colleague spots a practical workaround. The manager trying to handle three things at once says, “I need someone to take this,” and somebody does.
Those moments are meaningful. People get to see competence, generosity and judgement in action. They also get to experience being useful to one another.
The colleague whose requests usually arrive as another demand in your inbox becomes easier to understand when you see what their job requires. You discover why they need an answer quickly, what they are responsible for, and what happens when your part of the process stalls.
Perhaps you disagree about a decision. You explain your reasoning, hear theirs, and find a way forward. Later, when you need to have another difficult conversation, you have a previous one to build on.
The exercise gives the team a shared reference point: we have worked through something difficult together.
Make it a worthwhile experience
The experience should leave people feeling stretched and supported. People need a meaningful role, manageable pressure, and room to ask questions without embarrassment. Constant overload and humiliation have no place in the exercise brief.
Skilled facilitation keeps the challenge useful and makes space for people who might otherwise stay quiet. A facilitator who keeps adding disasters until everyone gives up has mainly demonstrated an enthusiasm for disasters.
Afterward, talk about what helped as well as what failed. Who made your job easier? What did you learn about another person’s role? Which contribution might have gone unnoticed if nobody mentioned it?
Fix the gaps the exercise revealed, then give the team another opportunity to practise. Let people experience the difference their improvements make.
The plan becomes more useful. People become more familiar with their responsibilities. Alongside that practical progress, there is an opportunity to build something harder to capture in a procedure: confidence in the people around you.
Later, someone asks, “Remember what happened in the exercise?” The team has something to draw on: decisions they made, help they gave, and a problem they worked through together.
When the next difficult day arrives, you want someone looking across the room and thinking, I’m glad you’re here.
Practice gives them a reason.
Request consultation